NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip Review: Is This $8 Lip Oil Actually Good?

Disclosure: This page contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

The NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip promises to deliver that coveted glossy, hydrated lip look for just $8. After three months of daily wear, I can tell you it's not perfect, but it's surprisingly good for the price point.

This isn't your typical tinted balm. The Fat Oil Lip Drip sits somewhere between a lip oil and a gloss, giving you that wet-look shine without the sticky mess most glosses leave behind. But is the NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip worth it when you can spend triple on Dior? Let's break it down.

What NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip Actually Does

The Fat Oil Lip Drip is NYX's attempt at the viral lip oil trend that's been dominating TikTok. It's a lightweight, oil-based formula that adds shine and subtle hydration to your lips. The "fat oil" name is pure marketing, but the product itself delivers on its basic promises.

I've been rotating through all 12 shades (yes, I have a problem), and the formula stays consistent across the range. The oil feels lightweight going on, never heavy or goopy like some drugstore lip products can be.

The applicator is a standard doe-foot, nothing fancy but it gets the job done. The tube itself feels cheap, I'll be honest. It's lightweight plastic that I wouldn't trust in my purse without a makeup bag.

Key Features That Actually Matter

The Formula

The oil base includes jojoba oil and vitamin E, which sounds impressive until you realize most lip products have these ingredients. What matters is how it performs, and surprisingly, it does hydrate without that artificial slick feeling.

The pigmentation varies wildly by shade. "Cake Batter" gives you barely-there tint, while "Berry Bliss" actually shows up on deeper skin tones. I wish NYX had been more consistent here.

Wear Time

This is where things get real. The Fat Oil Lip Drip lasts about 2-3 hours before you need to reapply. That's standard for lip oils, but don't expect the 6-hour wear some beauty influencers claim. I reapply after coffee, after lunch, and usually once more in the afternoon.

The Shine Factor

The glossy finish is the star here. It gives you that fresh, hydrated look without looking like you dunked your lips in petroleum jelly. The shine fades gradually, so you don't get that sudden "my lips look dead" moment.

Pricing Breakdown

The NYX option sits right in the middle for value, but you're getting less product than most competitors. Still, at $8, it's an easy impulse buy.

The Good: What NYX Got Right

The shine is legit. This delivers that glossy, healthy lip look that makes you look put-together even on lazy days. I've gotten compliments wearing nothing but this and mascara.

No sticky residue. Unlike traditional glosses, this doesn't leave that tacky feeling that makes your hair stick to your lips. You can actually drink coffee without creating a disaster.

Decent shade range. Twelve shades isn't groundbreaking, but there's something for most skin tones. "Glazed" is my go-to neutral, while "Cake Batter" works for that no-makeup makeup look.

Actually hydrating. My lips feel softer after wearing this, not dried out like some tinted products leave them. The jojoba oil isn't just for show.

The Bad: Where It Falls Short

Cheap packaging. The tube feels flimsy and the cap doesn't click securely. I've had one leak in my purse, which was annoying but not catastrophic.

Inconsistent pigmentation. Some shades are basically clear with a hint of tint, while others are surprisingly pigmented. There's no way to know until you buy it.

Short wear time. Three hours max before it's completely gone. That's not terrible, but it means constant reapplication if you want to maintain the look.

Limited hydration. It's better than nothing, but if your lips are actually dry or chapped, this won't fix the problem. It's maintenance hydration, not treatment.

How It Stacks Up Against the Competition

vs. Dior Lip Glow Oil

The Dior Lip Glow Oil costs nearly five times more, and honestly? It's better, but not $30 better.

Dior's formula lasts longer (4-5 hours), feels more luxurious, and the packaging is obviously superior. The cherry oil gives it a subtle scent that's actually pleasant. But for everyday wear, the NYX version gets you 80% of the way there for 20% of the price.

vs. Rare Beauty Soft Pinch Tinted Lip Oil

This is the closest competitor in terms of performance. Rare Beauty's version costs double but gives you more than double the product.

The Rare Beauty formula feels more substantial and lasts slightly longer. The shade range is more curated but smaller. If you're going to splurge on one mid-range lip oil, this is probably the better choice.

vs. Clarins Lip Comfort Oil

Clarins Lip Comfort Oil is the OG that started this whole trend. It's more expensive but significantly more hydrating. If you have genuinely dry lips, Clarins is worth the extra money.

The NYX version gives you the look without the treatment benefits. Clarins actually improves your lip condition over time.

vs. e.l.f. Glow Reviver Lip Oil

The e.l.f. option costs half as much but performs about half as well. The shine isn't as impressive and it disappears faster. NYX wins this one easily.

Shade Recommendations

After testing all 12 shades, here are the standouts:

"Glazed" - Perfect everyday neutral that works on most skin tones "Berry Bliss" - Actually shows up as a berry tint, great for fall "Cake Batter" - Subtle vanilla tint for the no-makeup look "Cosmic" - Surprisingly wearable purple-pink that's not as scary as it looks

Skip "Sunset" unless you love orange undertones, and "Clear" is pointless when you can get the same effect from regular lip balm.

Who Should Buy NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip

This works best for people who want the lip oil aesthetic without the premium price tag. If you're new to lip oils and want to test the waters, this is a solid starting point.

It's perfect for everyday wear when you want to look polished but not overdone. The subtle tint and shine work well for professional settings or casual days when you want that "your lips but better" effect.

College students and anyone on a tight beauty budget will appreciate getting a trendy look for under $10. It's also great for people who lose lip products constantly, since replacing an $8 tube doesn't hurt as much as losing a $38 Dior.

Who Should Skip It

If you have genuinely dry or chapped lips, this won't provide enough hydration. You need something more treatment-focused like the Clarins option.

People who want long-wearing lip color should look elsewhere. This is about the glossy effect, not lasting pigmentation.

If you're particular about packaging quality or hate reapplying lip products throughout the day, spend more on a premium option that performs better.

Is NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip Worth It?

For $8, yeah, it's worth trying. The Fat Oil Lip Drip delivers on its main promise of glossy, hydrated-looking lips without breaking the bank. It's not revolutionary, but it's a solid drugstore option that competes well with more expensive alternatives.

The formula works, the shades are mostly good, and the price point makes it an easy experiment. Just don't expect miracles from an $8 lip product.

Bottom Line

The NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip is a surprisingly decent drugstore lip oil that gives you the trendy glossy look for less than $10. While it can't match the longevity or luxury feel of premium options like Dior, it delivers 80% of the results for a fraction of the price. Buy it if you want to try the lip oil trend without the investment, but upgrade to something like Rare Beauty or Clarins if you fall in love with the category.